Eye (Cataract) Surgery Lawsuit

Recent lawsuits against eye surgeons highlight a growing trend, prompting questions about patient safety, the boundaries of medical responsibility, the legal implications surrounding eye surgery, and the options available to patients who experience unfortunate outcomes.

Key Takeaways

  • Eye surgery lawsuits are on the rise, with recent cases involving LASIK complications and a $6 million verdict for a failed cataract surgery.
  • Eye surgery is complex due to the delicate nature of the eye. Preoperative assessments are crucial to identify potential issues and ensure a successful outcome.
  • All eye surgeries carry inherent risks like infection, inflammation, vision disturbances, and bleeding. LASIK surgery has additional risks like dry eyes and visual disturbances.
  • Ophthalmologists can be sued for failing to meet the standard of care, including misdiagnosis, surgical errors, improper treatment, and inadequate post-surgical management.
  • If you suffer vision loss or complications from eye surgery, you may be entitled to compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and loss of quality of life.

Lawsuit Updates

Feb 2024

Eye Implant Recall Expands

Medical device manufacturer OmniTech expanded their recall of CrystalVue intraocular lenses (IOLs) on February 10th, 2024, due to a higher-than-expected rate of complications after surgery. This expansion is expected to significantly impact the ongoing lawsuit against OmniTech filed by multiple patients.

Jan 2024

Glaucoma Surgery Center Class Action Dismissed

A federal judge dismissed a class-action lawsuit against the California-based Glaucoma Surgery Center (GSC) on January 2nd, 2024. The lawsuit alleged deceptive advertising practices. The judge ruled that the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate sufficient evidence that they were harmed.

Sep 2023

$6 Million Award in Knoxville

Gerald McCoy received a $6 million award after losing an eye post-cataract surgery, marking one of the largest jury-awarded verdicts in Knox County's history. His wife, Deborah McCoy, was awarded $1 million for the failed procedure conducted in March 2017​.

May 2023

SouthEast Eye Specialists Settlement

SouthEast Eye Specialists and related entities agreed to a $17 million settlement for violating the Anti-Kickback Statute by inducing referrals for cataract surgeries. This case was litigated in the Middle District of Tennessee, highlighting the legal focus on ethical medical practices​.

Understanding Eye Surgery and Its Complexities

The field of ophthalmology encompasses a range of procedures and surgeries designed to correct various ocular disorders. These surgeries, while often enhancing vision and quality of life, carry inherent complexities due to the delicate and intricate nature of the eye.

How the Eye Works

The eye is a complex organ that orchestrates a sophisticated process to make vision possible. The best way to understand how the eye works is to compare to a camera. Just as a camera captures light to create an image, the eye collects light and processes it to produce the visual scenes we perceive.

The cornea is the eye's clear front layer, which acts as the primary lens that captures and directs light inward. Behind the cornea is the lens, a flexible structure that fine-tunes the focus of light rays to ensure sharp vision. The light then reaches the retina, a light-sensitive layer lining the back of the eye. Here, light is converted into electrical signals that are sent to the brain via the optic nerve.

Additionally, the iris plays a vital role in controlling the amount of light that enters the eye, functioning much like a camera's aperture. The optic nerve, then, is the critical conduit carrying visual information from the eye to the brain, enabling us to perceive the world around us.

All these layers work together to facilitate the complex process of seeing. This orchestration ensures that we can not only capture and focus light but also interpret it as the rich tapestry of images that form our visual experience.

Preoperative Findings

Before having eye surgery, patients typically undergo a preoperative phase, which is a series of detailed assessments conducted to evaluate their suitability for the procedure and to formulate a surgical plan. This pre-op phase encompasses various tests and evaluations.

For instance, doctors usually measure the visual acuity of the patient to assess the clarity of their vision and check the intraocular pressure to evaluate the risk of glaucoma. They also examine the health of the retina to ensure there are no underlying conditions that could complicate surgery.

In addition to these assessments, advanced imaging techniques are often utilized to obtain a detailed map of the eye's structure. The pre-op evaluation process is crucial for identifying eye conditions such as cataracts, retinal disorders, or corneal abnormalities.

The information gathered during the preoperative phase aids surgeons in determining the most suitable surgical approach and anticipating any potential challenges that may arise during the operation.

Intraoperative Issues

While performing eye surgery, the ophthalmologist may face numerous challenges due to the eye's complex structure and the need for meticulous precision.

These challenges arise as the surgeon navigates delicate tissues, manages bleeding, and addresses unforeseen complications such as lens dislocation or retinal tears. Additionally, complexities such as adjusting for the patient's unique anatomical variations or dealing with the opacity of ocular media can also obscure the surgeon's view.

To enhance the precision of the surgical procedure and to minimize the risk of complications, ophthalmologists rely on state-of-the-art surgical instruments and techniques.

Some of the advancements in eye surgery include laser technology for precise tissue removal and real-time imaging systems that provide a detailed view of the eye's internal structures during surgery. These technological advancements facilitate accurate and safe manipulation of delicate ocular components.

Postoperative Complications

After undergoing eye surgery, patients might experience complications such as infection, inflammation, or vision disturbances. Complications like these can arise from the invasive nature of the procedure, the body's reaction to surgical intervention, or pre-existing conditions that may hinder the healing process.

  • Infections can occur if bacteria enter the surgical site, leading to redness, pain, and discharge.
  • Inflammation is a common response that can cause discomfort and affect the eye's normal function.
  • Vision disturbances, such as blurriness or fluctuations in sight, can result from changes within the eye during surgery or as a reaction to the treatment.

For a successful recovery, immediate and appropriate management of these postoperative issues is essential. Administering medications like antibiotics to prevent infection and anti-inflammatory agents to reduce swelling are integral components of a well-rounded postoperative care regimen.

Additionally, scheduling regular follow-up visits to assess visual function and closely monitoring the eye's healing process are also an important part of a successful recovery process.

Have you encountered complications following eye surgery?

Issues arising from preoperative assessments, intraoperative challenges, or postoperative care can significantly impact your life and may entitle you to compensation.

Explore your legal options

Risks and Complications

While beneficial for many, eye surgery comes with inherent risks and complications. Patients who consider having eye surgery must understand the risks and complications involved before proceeding, and ensure they make informed decisions and adequately prepare for the procedure.

Common Risks

Eye surgeries, irrespective of their type, share a set of common risks. Like most surgeries, infection is a primary concern when operating, as bacteria or other pathogens can invade the surgical site, and lead to symptoms like increased redness, pain, and discharge.

Inflammation is another frequent complication, that can arise from the body's natural response to surgical trauma or from irritation caused by surgical materials or techniques. When it occurs, it can result in pain, swelling, and sometimes impaired vision, as the eye reacts to the invasive procedure.

Vision disturbances, such as blurred or double vision, can result from changes in the eye's internal structures or as a response to the surgery itself. Additionally, bleeding within the eye, known as hemorrhage, though rare, can have serious implications for visual acuity.

Last but not least, there's the risk of adverse reactions to anesthesia, which, while generally safe, can lead to complications in sensitive individuals. All in all, eye surgery is risky, and surgeons must employ extreme caution, meticulous techniques, and the best equipment available to minimize it.

Risks Associated with LASIK Surgery

LASIK surgery, specifically designed to correct refractive errors like myopia, hyperopia, and astigmatism, carries its own set of risks:

  • Dry eyes are a common postoperative complication associated with LASIK surgery, with patients often experiencing decreased tear production and discomfort.
  • Visual disturbances such as halos, glare, and difficulties with night vision are also reported, especially in the initial period following the surgery.
  • Undercorrections or overcorrections leading to less than optimal visual outcomes of the refractive error can occur during LASIK surgery as well. This side-effect may require additional surgery to correct.
  • Flap complications, while rare, represent a more serious risk, where the corneal flap created during the surgery does not heal properly or becomes dislodged.

Despite these risks, LASIK is known for its high success rate and satisfaction among patients. The key to minimizing complications lies in thorough preoperative screening to ensure suitability for the procedure, along with advanced surgical techniques and comprehensive postoperative care to manage any issues that arise.

Find out if you have a qualifying case

Legal Aspects of Eye Surgery Lawsuits

In recent times, eye surgery lawsuits have become more prominent, largely due to increased patient awareness and expectations. Eye surgeons who fail to meet the established standards of care, or who experience unfortunate outcomes despite best efforts, can face legal consequences.

What Are the Most Common Reasons Why Eye Doctors Are Sued?

Like in any other medical area, in the field of ophthalmology, legal disputes can arise from various aspects of clinical practice. The most common reasons eye doctors face lawsuits include:

  • Misdiagnosis: When an eye condition is incorrectly identified or overlooked, it can lead to inappropriate or delayed treatment, which in turn exacerbates the patient's condition and can potentially cause irreversible damage.
  • Surgical Errors: Errors during surgery, which may include performing the incorrect procedure or making technical mistakes during the operation, can cause serious harm to the patient. Consequences of such errors include loss of vision, persistent pain, or other significant complications.
  • Improper Treatment: Administering incorrect medications or therapies can worsen the patient's existing condition, trigger new health issues, or delay the administration of the correct course of treatment.
  • Inadequate Management of Postoperative Complications: Failing to properly manage complications after surgery can have serious consequences. If issues like infections, excessive inflammation, or vision impairment are not addressed promptly and effectively, it can lead to legal claims against the physician.

When an ophthalmologist commits one or more of the above lapses, they expose themselves to the risk of a lawsuit. Patients who suffer harm as a result of these lapses have the right to seek compensation and pursue accountability through a legal avenue.

Common Injuries that Result from Vision Care or Eye Surgery Errors

Injuries resulting from vision care or eye surgery errors are diverse and can have lasting impacts on a patient's life. Here's a more detailed look at common injuries, how they occur, and their implications:

  • Significant Vision Loss: Loss of vision can happen when a surgical procedure goes wrong, such as a lens being improperly implanted during cataract surgery, or due to a severe postoperative infection.
  • Complete Blindness: One of the most devastating outcomes, complete blindness may result from severe errors like cutting or damaging the optic nerve during surgery, or from unchecked postoperative infections that lead to the total loss of vision.
  • Persistent Pain: Patients can experience ongoing pain if nerves are damaged during surgery, or due to improperly managed postoperative inflammation and swelling.
  • Retinal Detachment: This serious condition can occur if the retina is damaged during surgery, leading to a separation of the retina from its underlying tissue, which can cause permanent vision loss if not treated promptly and effectively.
  • Infection: Surgical procedures introduce a risk of infection, which can lead to severe complications like endophthalmitis, a painful and potentially vision-threatening inflammation inside the eye.

These injuries are often the result of surgical mistakes, inadequate sterilization, or failure to properly monitor and manage the patient's postoperative recovery. They highlight the critical need for meticulous surgical technique, strict adherence to postoperative care protocols, and immediate response to any signs of complication.

Informed Consent

Informed consent in ophthalmology is not just a procedural formality. It is a fundamental aspect of patient care, emphasizing the need for patients to understand the risks, benefits, and alternatives of any proposed treatment or surgery.

This ethical imperative can lead to legal challenges when there is a discrepancy between patient expectations and surgical outcomes. Specifically, legal issues arise when patients experience unexpected complications or outcomes that fall short of their expectations, leading them to believe that they were not sufficiently informed before consenting to the procedure.

In these instances, legal actions can be initiated, with claims focusing on the adequacy and clarity of the information provided by the eye doctor, and whether it allowed the patient to make a truly informed and voluntary decision.

Vicarious Liability

Vicarious liability involves holding an employer or institution legally responsible for the actions of its employees or associates. In the context of eye care, this means that a healthcare facility, such as a hospital or clinic, can be sued for the negligent actions of its eye doctors or other medical staff.

Claims related to vicarious liability delve into the relationship between the healthcare provider and the personnel and scrutinize the nature of the alleged wrongdoing. They evaluate how the institution’s policies and oversight may have contributed to the incident and whether the organization could have done something to prevent the mishap.

In simpler terms, vicarious liability is about determining whether a healthcare institution should be held accountable for its employees' mistakes, based on its role in overseeing, training, and enforcing standards of care.

Understanding vicarious liability is essential for both individual practitioners and healthcare institutions to ensure proper protocols, training, and supervision are in place to prevent legal actions.

Explore your legal options today

Compensation and Legal Action

Following an eye surgery that resulted in vision-related injuries or complications, affected individuals may pursue legal compensation by filing a personal injury claim or initiating a lawsuit against the responsible party or parties, such as the medical facility, surgeon, or other healthcare professionals involved in the procedure.

What Compensation Can You Receive for Eye Surgery Complications or Vision Injury?

Individuals affected by eye surgery or vision-related errors are entitled to seek compensation to redress the wrongs and losses incurred. The types of financial recovery available for pursuit typically include:

  • Medical Expenses: Compensation that covers the costs of all medical treatments necessitated by the injury, including both past interventions and anticipated future medical needs.
  • Lost Wages: Patients can claim compensation for any earnings lost due to their inability to work while recovering from their injury or undergoing further treatments.
  • Pain and Suffering: Compensation that recognizes the physical pain and emotional distress experienced by the patient as a result of the medical error.
  • Loss of Quality of Life: When an injury leads to long-term changes in a patient's ability to engage in and enjoy daily activities and life’s pleasures, compensation can be sought for this diminished quality of life.

To secure such compensation, it is typically necessary for the patient to demonstrate the negligence of the healthcare provider and detail the consequent impact on their life, substantiating the claim with medical records, employment documents, and personal testimony.

Negotiating a Settlement Versus Litigating Your Case in Court

When seeking redress for complications or injuries resulting from eye surgery, patients can typically negotiate for a fair settlement, or attempt to fight for their justice in court.

Settlement refers to an agreement reached between the plaintiff (patient) and the responsible party, often a healthcare provider or institution, without going to trial. It is a process that involves negotiation, where both sides agree on a compensation amount to resolve the claim.

Settlements are common because they can provide a quicker resolution to the dispute, guaranteeing the patient some level of compensation while avoiding the public exposure and uncertainty of a trial.

Litigation, on the other hand, is the process of taking legal action in court. Typically, litigation is pursued when a satisfactory agreement cannot be reached through negotiation. If the court rules in the patient's favor, litigation may lead to higher compensation, but it involves more risks and uncertainties.

The drawbacks of litigation include the public nature of court proceedings, the possibility of an appeal which can prolong the process, and the chance of losing the case, which could result in receiving no compensation at all.

Recover the compensation you rightfully deserve

Medical Conditions Ophthalmologists Treat

Ophthalmologists treat a wide range of conditions, most of which can lead to complications or adverse outcomes. The complex nature of ophthalmic treatments means that even with the best efforts, things can go wrong. Conditions such as:

  • Cataracts: The clouding of the eye’s lens is commonly treated with surgery. If the surgery results in unexpected complications or fails to improve vision as anticipated, it could lead to legal action.
  • Glaucoma: This group of conditions can cause optic nerve damage due to high intraocular pressure. The failure to diagnose, treat, or manage glaucoma properly can result in vision loss, making it a frequent subject of medical malpractice claims.
  • Retinal Detachments: A serious condition where the retina separates from its support tissue requires immediate surgical intervention. Errors in diagnosis or treatment can lead to permanent vision loss and are significant grounds for legal claims.
  • Refractive Errors: Conditions like myopia, hyperopia, and astigmatism are commonly corrected through procedures like LASIK. However, surgical errors or postoperative complications can lead to unsatisfactory outcomes and potential lawsuits.

Experimental Procedures and Consent

Like in other medical fields, experimental procedures represent the forefront of scientific progress in ophthalmology. They offer new possibilities for treatments but also pose distinct ethical and legal challenges.

Consent in these situations requires a thorough grasp of the experimental nature of the treatment, including its potential risks, benefits, and uncertainties, beyond what's typical for standard medical procedures

What If the Procedure Is Experimental?

Experimental procedures in ophthalmology, often conducted within clinical trials or as part of a research program, are designed to test the safety, efficacy, and outcomes of innovative treatments. They can range from new surgical techniques to pioneering drug therapies or cutting-edge technology applications.

When a procedure is considered experimental, it is crucial that all parties involved especially the patient understand its novel nature. Informed consent for experimental procedures involves several key elements:

  • Detailed Explanation: Patients must receive a thorough explanation of the procedure, including its experimental status, the stage of research, and the difference from standard treatments.
  • Risks and Benefits: The potential risks and benefits of the experimental procedure must be clearly outlined, including how they compare to those of traditional treatment options.
  • Voluntariness: Consent must be given voluntarily, without any coercion or undue influence, and patients should feel free to ask questions and take time to decide.
  • Right to Withdraw: Patients should be informed of their right to withdraw from the experimental treatment at any stage without jeopardizing their standard of care.

The decision to participate in an experimental procedure involves weighing the potential for personal health benefits against the risks and uncertainties associated with unproven treatments.

Both patients and doctors must engage in an open, transparent dialogue to ensure that the decision to proceed is well-informed and considerate of the patient’s health, values, and preferences.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, if you've suffered significant harm from negligent cataract surgery, you can sue for medical malpractice to seek compensation.

Ophthalmologists face relatively frequent litigation, with malpractice suits being more common compared to some other specialties, often due to the high expectations and risks associated with eye surgeries.

The most frequent cause of malpractice claims in optometry is the misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis of ocular conditions, leading to improper or delayed treatment.

See if you have a viable case to file a claim

Notable Lawsuits

Explore your legal options

Submit your inquiry through our contact form to start your search for legal assistance. Our directory connects you with experienced lawyers in a variety of practice areas, ensuring you have access to advice when you need it most.

  1. Nationwide database
  2. Experienced professionals