Home
Glossary
I
Illusory Promise

What Is Illusory Promise?

An illusory promise is a statement that appears to be a promise but does not actually bind the party making it to any obligation or performance. Because it lacks commitment, an illusory promise cannot be enforced as a contract.

Illusory Promise Explained

An illusory promise gives the impression that a party is making a commitment, but upon closer examination, it reveals that the party retains the discretion to fulfill or not fulfill the promise. This means that the promise lacks mutuality, which is a fundamental requirement for a legally binding contract.

Key Characteristics of an Illusory Promise:

Lack of Obligation: The promisor does not actually commit to a specific action or forbearance.

Discretion: The promisor retains the right to choose whether to perform the promised act, making the promise unenforceable.

Lack of Mutuality: Both parties are not bound by reciprocal obligations, which is essential for a contract.

Examples:

- "I will buy your car if I feel like it."

- "I will employ you as long as it suits me."

The Term Illusory Promise in Different Legal Contexts

United States: In U.S. contract law, an illusory promise cannot form the basis of a valid contract because it fails to create a mutual obligation. Courts will not enforce a contract where one party's promise is illusory. For instance, under the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), a requirements contract where a buyer agrees to purchase "all the goods I want" would be considered illusory.

United Kingdom: In UK law, the principle is similar. A contract requires consideration (something of value exchanged between the parties), and an illusory promise would fail to provide such consideration. The courts in the UK will also look for a clear intent to create legal relations, which is absent in the case of an illusory promise.

Australia: Australian contract law also adheres to the principle that a promise must be definite and certain to be enforceable. An illusory promise, which leaves performance at the discretion of the promisor, would not meet the requirement of mutual agreement and consideration.

Common Misconceptions About the Meaning of Illusory Promise

A common misconception is that any promise conditional on a future event is illusory. This is not true. A conditional promise can be enforceable if the condition is specific and outside the control of the promisor. For example, "I will buy your car if I secure financing" is not illusory because the promisor has an obligation contingent on obtaining financing.

Another misconception is that all promises made in the context of a contract are enforceable. In reality, only promises that meet the legal requirements of offer, acceptance, consideration, and mutuality of obligation are enforceable. Illusory promises fail to meet these criteria because they do not genuinely bind the promisor.

There is also a misconception that courts can "fix" an illusory promise to make it enforceable. While courts can sometimes interpret unclear terms or imply reasonable obligations, they cannot enforce a promise that fundamentally lacks commitment. If a promise is deemed illusory, the entire contract or that particular provision may be invalidated.

Recommendations

0 reviews

Drew Davis Van De Grift

Contracts and Agreements Lawyer Serving at Birmingham - Michigan

1895 Bradford Rd, Michigan, 48009-7253

Thomas M. Cooley
Contracts and Agreements, Freedom of Information Act, Government Contracts, Employment and Labor, State, Local And Municipal Law, Government and Tax
Birmingham, Michigan Contracts and Agreements Lawyer

Free Consultation

+12486353360

What Is Illusory Promise?

Illusory Promise Explained

The Term Illusory Promise in Different Legal Contexts

Common Misconceptions About the Meaning of Illusory Promise

Share

Recommendations

Written by Michael Anderson

UPDATED Jul 05,2024

Written by Michael Anderson

UPDATED Jul 03,2024

Written by Michael Anderson

UPDATED Jul 02,2024

Written by Michael Anderson

UPDATED Jul 08,2024

Written by Michael Anderson

UPDATED Jul 08,2024

Written by Michael Anderson

UPDATED Jun 15,2024

Written by Michael Anderson

UPDATED Jun 14,2024

Written by Michael Anderson

UPDATED Jun 13,2024

Written by Michael Anderson

UPDATED Jun 11,2024

Log in to your account

Contact