What Is the Best Evidence Rule?

The Best Evidence Rule is a principle of evidence law that requires the original document or a reliable duplicate to be presented as evidence in court when the contents of that document are in dispute.

This rule applies primarily to written documents but can extend to recordings and photographs, depending on jurisdictional specifics. The aim is to prevent inaccuracies and misunderstandings that might arise from relying on secondary evidence, such as a copy or a recollection, thus ensuring the highest degree of reliability in legal proceedings.

Best Evidence Rule Explained

The Best Evidence Rule stipulates that when a party seeks to prove the content of a document, the original document itself is the most reliable source of information and therefore should be produced as evidence. If the original is unavailable, a valid reason must be provided, and only then can secondary evidence, such as copies or oral testimonies, be potentially admissible.

This rule is particularly important in cases where the document's details are crucial to the dispute's outcome, such as contracts in breach of contract cases, wills in estate disputes, or written agreements in business litigation.

Exceptions to the Best Evidence Rule include:

When originals have been lost or destroyed, without fault of the proponent.

When originals cannot be obtained by any available judicial process.

When the document is not closely related to the controlling issues in the case.

When the document is a public record and a certified copy is available.

The Term Best Evidence Rule in Different Legal Contexts

Criminal Law: Ensuring that the evidence presented is as accurate and untampered with as possible is crucial, especially in cases where documentary evidence can prove or disprove elements of the crime.

Contract Law: The content of contractual agreements often forms the basis of disputes, making the Best Evidence Rule critical in litigation over alleged breaches of contract.

Intellectual Property Law: Original designs, patents, or trademark registrations may be subject to the Best Evidence Rule when their contents are disputed in infringement lawsuits.

Common Misconceptions About the Meaning of Best Evidence Rule

Only Original Documents Are Admissible: While the Best Evidence Rule prioritizes original documents, it does allow for exceptions where originals are unavailable, and reliable copies or secondary evidence can be used.

Applies to All Types of Evidence: A common misunderstanding is that the Best Evidence Rule applies to all evidence presented in court. In reality, it specifically applies to disputes over the content of documents. Other types of evidence, such as physical evidence or witness testimony, are governed by different rules.

Digital Copies Are Never Acceptable: With advancements in technology, high-quality digital reproductions can sometimes serve as acceptable substitutes for originals under the Best Evidence Rule, depending on the jurisdiction and the circumstances under which the digital copy was created and maintained.

Share

Recommendations

Drew Davis Van De Grift

Contracts and Agreements Lawyer Serving at Birmingham - Michigan

1895 Bradford Rd, Michigan, 48009-7253
  • Thomas M. Cooley
  • Contracts and Agreements, Freedom of Information Act, Government Contracts, Employment and Labor, State, Local And Municipal Law, Government and Tax
  • Birmingham, Michigan Contracts and Agreements Lawyer

0 reviews

Lawyer Serving at Birmingham - Michigan

1895 Bradford Rd, Michigan, 48009-7253

Paul J. Carrier

Contracts and Agreements Lawyer Serving at Brighton - Michigan

224 N 1st St, Michigan, 48116-1205
  • Contracts and Agreements and International Law
  • Brighton, Michigan Contracts and Agreements Lawyer

0 reviews

Lawyer Serving at Brighton - Michigan

224 N 1st St, Michigan, 48116-1205

Mustapha Nabil Hawily

Business Lawyer Serving at Dearborn - Michigan

23756 Michigan Ave Ste 300, Michigan, 48124-1853
  • University of Detroit Mercy School of Law
  • Business, Criminal Defense, Family, Immigration and Personal Injury
  • Dearborn, Michigan Business Lawyer

0 reviews

Lawyer Serving at Dearborn - Michigan

23756 Michigan Ave Ste 300, Michigan, 48124-1853

Christopher J. Johnson

Civil Rights Lawyer Serving at Ann Arbor - Michigan

1675 Green Rd, Michigan, 48105-2530
  • Michigan State University College of Law
  • Civil Rights, Freedom of Information Act, Government Contracts, Insurance, State, Local And Municipal Law, Government and Police Misconduct
  • Ann Arbor, Michigan Civil Rights Lawyer

0 reviews

Lawyer Serving at Ann Arbor - Michigan

1675 Green Rd, Michigan, 48105-2530

Jessamyne Marie Kalabat

Commercial Lawyer Serving at Farmington Hills - Michigan

31440 Northwestern Hwy Ste 145, Michigan, 48334-5420
  • University of Detroit Mercy School of Law
  • Commercial, Contracts and Agreements, Environmental and Natural Resources, Litigation, Probate and Real Estate
  • Farmington Hills, Michigan Commercial Lawyer

0 reviews

Lawyer Serving at Farmington Hills - Michigan

31440 Northwestern Hwy Ste 145, Michigan, 48334-5420

Sean Christopher Etheridge

Business Lawyer Serving at Ann Arbor - Michigan

789 N Dixboro Rd, Michigan, 48105-9723
  • Business, Commercial, Contracts and Agreements, Health Care, Licensing and Securities Offerings
  • Ann Arbor, Michigan Business Lawyer

0 reviews

Lawyer Serving at Ann Arbor - Michigan

789 N Dixboro Rd, Michigan, 48105-9723

Lynda D. McGhee

Juvenile Lawyer Serving at Hamtramck - Michigan

2933 Caniff St Unit 12250, Michigan, 48212-4712
  • Juvenile and Probate
  • Hamtramck, Michigan Juvenile Lawyer

0 reviews

Lawyer Serving at Hamtramck - Michigan

2933 Caniff St Unit 12250, Michigan, 48212-4712

Damir Junicic

Workers Compensation Law Lawyer Serving at Los Angeles - California

Law Office of Damir Junicic, 10880 Wilshire Blvd Ste 1101, California, 90024-4112
  • Workers Compensation Law
  • Los Angeles, California Workers Compensation Law Lawyer
Free Consultation +13107535155

0 reviews

Lawyer Serving at Los Angeles - California

Law Office of Damir Junicic, 10880 Wilshire Blvd Ste 1101, California, 90024-4112
Free Consultation +13107535155

Nicholas Joseph Schroeck

Environmental and Natural Resources Lawyer Serving at Detroit - Michigan

651 E Jefferson Ave, Michigan, 48226-4349
  • Wayne State University School of Law
  • Environmental and Natural Resources
  • Detroit, Michigan Environmental and Natural Resources Lawyer

0 reviews

Lawyer Serving at Detroit - Michigan

651 E Jefferson Ave, Michigan, 48226-4349

David S. Nows

Business Lawyer Serving at Mount Pleasant - Michigan

164 Grawn Hall, Michigan, 48859-0001
  • University of Pennsylvania Law School
  • Business, Contracts and Agreements, Immigration, Mergers and Acquisitions, Divestitures, Public Finance and Tax Exempt Finance, Securities Offerings, Sports and Tax
  • Mount Pleasant, Michigan Business Lawyer

0 reviews

Lawyer Serving at Mount Pleasant - Michigan

164 Grawn Hall, Michigan, 48859-0001